• Big Story
  • News
    • News
    • Consumer Technology
    • Market Updates
    • Technology Insights
  • Interviews
  • Opinion
  • Digital Transformation Series
  • Special Reports
    • MWC Africa
    • Nigeria 5G Spectrum Auction
Wednesday, July 16, 2025
  • Login
  • Register
Technology Times | Latest and Breaking Nigeria Tech News
No Result
View All Result
Technology Times | Latest and Breaking Nigeria Tech News
No Result
View All Result
Technology Times | Latest and Breaking Nigeria Tech News
No Result
View All Result
Your text

Does Shamsuna know about the digital transformation agenda?

Yunusa YaubyYunusa Yau
31/07/2022
in Columns
Reading Time: 7 mins read
1 0
A A
0
ADVERTISEMENT

Some months back, I had separate meetings with the Minister of Communication and Digital Economy and the Director General of the National Information Technology Development Agency (NITDA) during which both spoke glowingly about the Digital Transformation Agenda of Nigeria, and of what they were doing to ensure that Nigeria leverages digital technology to transform its economy and society. 

The National Digital Economy Policy and Strategy, which is the vehicle for the digital transformation of the country has the vision of making “Nigeria into a leading digital economy, providing quality life and digital economies for all” with a mission that commits that the country to building “a nation where digital innovation and entrepreneurship are used to create value and prosperity for all.”

The strategy rests on eight pillars among which are hard infrastructure, soft infrastructure, and service infrastructure. The idea of developing infrastructure is to address accessibility challenges and make digital infrastructure available to citizens, an important pre-condition for the digital transformation of the country. But while infrastructure is necessary, it is not a sufficient condition for the envisaged transformation. Infrastructure cannot on its own add value to anything. It is only when people use it that it can be of any use.  For this reason, another of the pillars of the transformation agenda is Digital Literacy & Skills. This pillar requires digital literacy with a target of 90% by 2025.

However, even with skill, we are still far from being able to use technology to transform the country. People must use both their skills and the infrastructure, Actual use of these is dependent on affordability. Affordability is an economic matter. Technically, it is the ability of people to afford digital services without injuring other critical needs such as food, shelter, health, etc. As a function of economic status, affordability is different for different people. Poor people generally have lower affordability. To level up and promote universal affordability, countries use regulation to bridge gaps in affordability profiles. They also have relevant vehicles to do this. 

In Nigeria, the Universal Service Provision Fund (USPF) is the vehicle which is funded through a profit tax on telecommunication services. The USPF tries to drive infrastructure and connectivity to areas where the market has failed. This bridging accessibility makes Developmental Regulation to be another important pillar for the digital transformation strategy. 

In concrete terms, affordability is about both the cost of ownership of means of interfacing with digital technology and the cost of its use. The essence of regulation is to improve affordability by bridging the two cost components. Since we hardly manufacture digital devices locally, the cost of ownership is determined by the floating value of the Naira which means that in this period when the Naira is on a free fall, this dimension of affordability is decreasing, with many Nigerians being unable to own devices. Nigeria is one of the countries with the highest volume of importation of second-hand electronic devices, many of which properly could be passed as e-waste. Government seems to be doing nothing about this.

Related Articles

Nigeria‘s digital health drive to boost access, FG says

Nigeria launches national web portal to drive inclusive volunteerism

Tinubu pushes tech-driven tax reforms 

Minister: To block global fugitives, Nigeria linking expatriate database to INTERPOL

#Watch: Technology Times Thought Leadership Series #Live

Photos: Katsina unfolds GovOps to empower civil servants for digital transformation

Cross River State plans ₦5 billion upgrade of healthcare services

Nigeria outlines digital transformation plan for education sector

Cross River State Governor tasks journalists on adoption of modern technology ‘for better information dissemination’

Ebonyi Hackathon hopes to drive digital transformation in Nigeria’s lowest connectivity state

Maybe because Shamsuna’s life revolves around Abuja, Kaduna, and flights to Davos and other financial capitals of the world that she cannot imagine the havoc her policy will wreak on affordability in the country. Unlike her, my life frequently intersects with communities that are not on any map. They include names such as Kabigel, Digiza, Jogayel, all of them on the eastern bank of River Jamaare.

Y. Z. Yau.

Now the second cost component, that of use, is under attack from the Minister of Finance Budget and National Planning, Madam Shamsuna Zainab Ahmed. She is pushing to raise the VAT on telecommunication use from 7.5% to 12.5%. This is in spite of the fact as studies by the Alliance for Affordable Internet (A4AI) have shown, Nigeria has now the highest cost of use for both voice and data in Africa. Her interest is to raise revenue for the country without consideration of the likely impact of this on the digital transformation agenda. She seems to think about revenue as an end rather than a means to an end. Already more than half of the population is digitally excluded and with this proposed policy, many more people will have to fall off the ladder of the digital world.

Maybe because Shamsuna’s life revolves around Abuja, Kaduna, and flights to Davos and other financial capitals of the world that she cannot imagine the havoc her policy will wreak on affordability in the country. Unlike her, my life frequently intersects with communities that are not on any map. They include names such as Kabigel, Digiza, Jogayel, all of them on the eastern bank of River Jamaare. Each time I want to speak to anyone from these communities, I must travel there because I cannot get them using my GSM. Shamsuna would not understand what I found there. Many of the youth have handsets but they do not have SIM cards in their handsets. They listen to MP3 from their handsets, bringing music of various genres to them. When I asked them why it is that they have handsets but no sim cards, the answer they give tells a classic of regulation.

First, they said that when their sim cards spoil or get lost, it is difficult for them to get a replacement: this is something that Prof. Pantami, the Minster, and Prof. Danbatta, the Executive Vice Chairman of the Nigeria Communication Commission (NCC) would have to find how to address. The one that concerns Shamsuna is that they said even where they have sim cards, they cannot afford airtime, and they rather keep the sim cards home so that it does not either get lost or damaged. With this proposal of raising VAT, many more people will join ranks of those who cannot afford usage and keep their sim cards for decoration at home or for showing to their grandchildren that they too understand the digital era. This is not just rural people. I recall the response of a friend, who was a PhD holder in Computer Science, who once complained to me that he could understand why he had to buy rice, Maggi and other foodstuff but not having to buy “air”, referring to airtime!

There is another thing that the elite culture of the circles in which Shamsuna inhabits will not allow her to know. Many of the people in these rural and poor communities have not been sucked by the individualism of the capitalist system. So, whereas the likes of the Minister have only a “hello” to say to their relatives or neighbours when they speak on phone (unless they are discussing business or office contracts), these rural folks live by a sense of communal responsibility. So, when one calls the other, he or she first asks about all the people in the household of the other, referring to each by name. Then after, he or she switches to other important elements in the household such as the farms, the animals, the weather, etc. Once she or he finishes, it is not yet time to hang up. It is now the turn of the called party to also ask about the household of the call initiator. When this lengthy greeting is over, the call initiator then introduces the purpose of the call. In this way, telecommunication companies smile to the banks handsomely even as they wonder what on earth makes these people spend this long on the phone. In other words, while in the past, telecoms providers could say the telephone was not for the poor, now telecommunication companies recognize that the poor constitute a top demography of their line utilization. 

 I am not an economist but a mere digital justice campaigner, however, I know Shamsuna’s VAT policy is faulty in two senses, at least with respect to the digital transformation ambition of the country. 

First, by raising the cost of use, she will drastically reduce the number of users and the volume of tele-traffic. Once the tele-traffic drops, that means telecommunication and related value addition companies will see their revenue dropping. So, while on paper her VAT collection from the individual users may increase, the volume of company tax contribution to the revenue profile of the country will reduce, providing a net negative growth in the collectible revenue from the telecommunication sector. 

But things do not just stop at the reduction in company income tax. Access to digital technology is not just for social interactions. It is about using technology for economic activities. It is these economic activities that could transform the country. By making it difficult for people to make use of digital technology, Shamsuna hampers the economic activities that could aggregate into transforming the country. She will also be hampering economic activities and undermining her VAT drive. 

At the time the country is seeking all means to improve both accessibility and affordability, Shamsuna directly attacks affordability while the ripple effect of her policy will, because it will result in a decrease in usage, make companies to no longer be eager to expand their telecommunication infrastructure, and this undermines the accessibility equation. Without expanding infrastructure, one of the key important targets of the Government as spelt out in the National Broadband Plan of driving broadband penetration to 90% of the population cannot be achieved.  This is a critical requirement for the digital transformation of the country as we cannot rely on the world-wide-wait speed of non-broadband access to fire the process. Shamsuna’s VAT drive spells doom for this.

So, in the end, one can ask the Finance Minister whether she knows about the digital transformation agenda, and if she does, whether she understands the place of the agenda in the reshaping the economy of the country that she is supposed to be coordinating, and its ultimate transformation into a leading digital economy providing quality life and digital economies for all? Whatever the answers, this illustrates one painful reality of national economic management. It is the extreme lack of coherence within government such that different ministers work across purposes. Such zero-sum management will surely neither achieve the agenda of reviving the economy nor achieve the sectoral goals of different ministers. But digital transformation is too important to be left at the whims of sectoral predilection of ministers. 

I close this piece by drawing attention to what my ex-Kuranga colleague, Gbenga Adebayo, Chairman, Association of Licensed Telecom Owners of Nigeria (ALTON) said about the policy: the “burden would be on telecommunications consumers”. That is no statement from an activist and I hope both the public and the government take note of this and call the Minster to order.

Tags: digital transformationdigital transformationsVATy z yau
Share24Tweet15Share4SendShare
Yunusa Yau

Yunusa Yau

Related Articles

fg-nigeria-digital-health-drive-to-boost-access
News

Nigeria‘s digital health drive to boost access, FG says

byIretomiwa Balogun
30/06/2025
nigeria-launches-web-portal-for-volunteerism
News

Nigeria launches national web portal to drive inclusive volunteerism

byIretomiwa Balogun
16/05/2025
tinubu-pushes-tech-driven-tax-reforms
News

Tinubu pushes tech-driven tax reforms 

byIretomiwa Balogun
15/05/2025
-nigeria-links-expatriate-database-to-interpol
News

Minister: To block global fugitives, Nigeria linking expatriate database to INTERPOL

byOladapo Riliwan
22/04/2025
#Watch: Technology Times Thought Leadership Series #Live
News

#Watch: Technology Times Thought Leadership Series #Live

byTechnology Times Staff
20/03/2025
photos-katsina-unfolds-govops-for-workers
Photo News

Photos: Katsina unfolds GovOps to empower civil servants for digital transformation

byOladapo Riliwan
20/01/2025
cross-river-state-plans-₦5b-healthcare-upgrade
News

Cross River State plans ₦5 billion upgrade of healthcare services

byIretomiwa Balogun
14/01/2025
nigerias-digital-transformation-for-education
News

Nigeria outlines digital transformation plan for education sector

byIretomiwa Balogun
13/01/2025
cross-river-state-governor-tasks-journalists-on-fechnology
News

Cross River State Governor tasks journalists on adoption of modern technology ‘for better information dissemination’

byIretomiwa Balogun
06/01/2025
ebonyi-hackathon-drives-digital-transformation
Interviews

Ebonyi Hackathon hopes to drive digital transformation in Nigeria’s lowest connectivity state

byFejiro Awowede
18/11/2024

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

I agree to the Terms & Conditions and Privacy Policy.

2 × 5 =

UBA Ad UBA Ad UBA Ad
ADVERTISEMENT
Access Bank Access Bank Access Bank
ADVERTISEMENT
First Bank AD First Bank AD First Bank AD
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT

Latest Articles

nigeria-immigration-begins-digital-cerpac-aug-1

Nigeria Immigration begins digital CERPAC rollout August 1

16/07/2025
mtn-mtv-base-fight-online-abuse-of-africa-youth

MTN, MTV Base team up against online abuse of African youth

16/07/2025
Samsung unfolds Galaxy Z Fold7: ‘Slimmest, lightest foldable yet’

Samsung unfolds Galaxy Z Fold7: ‘Slimmest, lightest foldable yet’

16/07/2025
paradigm-initiative-pushes-gamified-digital-rights

Paradigm Initiative targets 20 million students with gamified digital rights

16/07/2025
sec-flags-scam-by-forsman-&-bodenfors-impersonator

SEC warns Nigerians against ponzi scheme masquerading as Swedish AD agency Forsman & Bodenfors

16/07/2025
CrownCrystal Technologies CrownCrystal Technologies CrownCrystal Technologies
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT

POPULAR ARTICLES

  • sec-flags-scam-by-forsman-&-bodenfors-impersonator

    SEC warns Nigerians against ponzi scheme masquerading as Swedish AD agency Forsman & Bodenfors

    52 shares
    Share 21 Tweet 13
  • FG signals inclusive review of Nigeria’s Cybercrime Act

    72 shares
    Share 29 Tweet 18
  • Why the Xiaomi 13T smartphone remains a contender among flagship

    94 shares
    Share 38 Tweet 24
  • Nine Nigerians sentenced for internet fraud, EFCC says 

    75 shares
    Share 30 Tweet 19
  • Operation Red Card: Nigeria leads continental crackdown on cybercrime syndicates

    79 shares
    Share 32 Tweet 20
  • FG suspends MultiChoice’s price hike in Nigeria

    97 shares
    Share 39 Tweet 24
  • B’Odogwu: Nigeria Customs hits ₦6.1 trillion revenue record with local digital platform

    142 shares
    Share 57 Tweet 36
  • Remita, Nigeria’s payment powerhouse, eyes Pan-African expansion, crosses ₦60 trillion mark

    115 shares
    Share 46 Tweet 29
  • Increased risk of fraud during times of economic uncertainty

    77 shares
    Share 31 Tweet 19
  • GSMA: AI, 5G to pump $18 trillion into world economy by 2035

    77 shares
    Share 31 Tweet 19

Latest Videos

  • TT TV
teniola-advocates-dynamic-billing-for-nigerians

Teniola advocates dynamic billing to protect Nigerian consumers | Technology Times Policy eXchange

14/04/2025
watch-mtn-nigeria-board-lawsuit-interview

#Watch: MTN Nigeria’s board is filled with ex-regulators—is this a conflict of interest?

24/03/2025
engr-banjo-on-local-content-in-nigeris-telecoms

Watch: Engr. Banjo on local content in Nigeria’s telecoms market

23/03/2025
#Watch: Technology Times Thought Leadership Series #Live

#Watch: Technology Times Thought Leadership Series #Live

20/03/2025
#Watch Technology Times TV #Live

#Watch Technology Times TV #Live

20/03/2025
Load More
ADVERTISEMENT
Facebook Twitter Youtube LinkedIn RSS

ABOUT TECHNOLOGY TIMES

technology-times-logo

Nigeria Technology Media Group

Founded in 2004, Technology Times’ trusted technology news, market intelligence, views and business services reach readers and partners across Nigeria, Africa and beyond.

Advertising

Sign up for TT eNews

Get in touch here

CONTACT US

Phone: +234 (0) 1 454 1818
WhatsApp: +234 (0) 815 700 0100
Email: info@technologytimes.ng
Web: www.technologytimes.ng

LEGAL & COMPLIANCE

technology-times-logoHome

TT Privacy Policy

TT Terms & Conditions

TT Website Disclaimer

TT Guest Post Guidelines

TT Sitemap

VOffice

TOP STORIES

  • sec-flags-scam-by-forsman-&-bodenfors-impersonator

    SEC warns Nigerians against ponzi scheme masquerading as Swedish AD agency Forsman & Bodenfors

    52 shares
    Share 21 Tweet 13
  • FG signals inclusive review of Nigeria’s Cybercrime Act

    72 shares
    Share 29 Tweet 18
  • Why the Xiaomi 13T smartphone remains a contender among flagship

    94 shares
    Share 38 Tweet 24
  • Nine Nigerians sentenced for internet fraud, EFCC says 

    75 shares
    Share 30 Tweet 19

©2004-2025 Technology Times, owned and operated by Digital Transformation Media Limited (DTML), Nigeria or its affiliates. All rights reserved.

Welcome Back!

Sign In with Facebook
Sign In with Google
OR

Login to your account below

Forgotten Password? Sign Up

Create New Account!

Sign Up with Facebook
Sign Up with Google
OR

Fill the forms below to register

*By registering into our website, you agree to the Terms & Conditions and Privacy Policy.
All fields are required. Log In

Retrieve your password

Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

Log In

Add New Playlist

No Result
View All Result
  • Big Story
  • News
    • News
    • Consumer Technology
    • Market Updates
    • Technology Insights
  • Interviews
  • Opinion
  • Digital Transformation Series
  • Special Reports
    • MWC Africa
    • Nigeria 5G Spectrum Auction
  • Login
  • Sign Up

©2004-2025 Technology Times, owned and operated by Digital Transformation Media Limited (DTML), Nigeria or its affiliates. All rights reserved.

This website uses cookies. By continuing to use this website you are giving consent to cookies being used. Visit our Privacy Policy Page.