Nigeria says it has secured a final arbitral victory against European Dynamics UK Ltd in a ₦8.35 billion ($6.2 million) dispute arising from a national electronic Government Procurement (eGP) project.
The victory relieves the Federal Government of potential financial exposure estimated at over ₦8.35 billion in claimed payments and damages, according to a statement issued by the Office of the Attorney General of the Federation (AGF) seen by Technology Times.
The arbitration, which is final and not subject to appeal, dismissed the contractor’s claims in their entirety, the AGF says.
The dispute involved the Bureau of Public Procurement (BPP) and the UK-based technology contractor over the design and implementation of a national e-Procurement platform for the Federal Government of Nigeria.
Prior to Dr Adedokun’s appointment, discussions had reportedly taken place around an out-of-court settlement. However, the Bureau elected to continue with the arbitral process, maintaining that payments must be tied strictly to demonstrable value delivered.
Genesis of dispute with European Dynamics UK Ltd
Upon assuming office, the Director-General of the BPP, Dr Adebowale Adedokun, inherited a stalled technology project alongside ongoing arbitration proceedings. European Dynamics UK Ltd had claimed approximately $2.4 million for alleged milestone completions, ₦4.04 billion ($3 million) in general damages and an additional ₦1.07 billion ($800,000) in settlement claims.
Prior to Dr Adedokun’s appointment, discussions had reportedly taken place around an out-of-court settlement. However, the Bureau elected to continue with the arbitral process, maintaining that payments must be tied strictly to demonstrable value delivered.
Nigeria’s legal team was led by Johnson & Wilner LLP, a Nigerian business and technology law firm, with Basil Udotai Esq., Founding Partner, leading the arbitration together with the firm’s strategic partners and associates.
The underlying contract concerned the design, development/customisation, supply, installation and maintenance of a national electronic Government Procurement (eGP) system financed with support from the World Bank. The project was intended to strengthen transparency, accountability and efficiency across federal public procurement processes.
What is the Nigeria e-Procurement system (eGP)?
According to information published on the company’s website, the eGP system was conceived as an end-to-end digital procurement platform covering the full public procurement lifecycle: from planning and tender publication to bid submission, evaluation, contract award and contract management. The platform was designed to integrate federal ministries, departments and agencies into a unified digital framework, with modules structured in implementation phases.
Technology Times checks on the also shows that European Dynamics had in the preceding year announced that it has secured a World Bank funded Framework Agreement to implement e-Government Procurement to 35 Nigerian States.
“The Bureau of Public Procurement (BPP) of Nigeria,” the company says in the information dated September 24, 2021, “has awarded to ED a World Bank funded contract for the design, development/customization, supply, installation and maintenance of the e-Government Procurement (e-GP) System at Federal level for the Government of Nigeria.”
European Dynamics says its “e-PPS Electronic Procurement platform shall be implemented to cover e-Registration, e-Procurement Planning, e-Publication/Notification, e-Tendering, e-Evaluation/Awarding, e-Contract Management, e-Catalogue Management, e-Purchasing as well as Business Intelligence Reporting and Dashboard.”
According to ED, “The contract followed a very competitive international call for tenders involving fifteen companies and it has a five-year duration extendable to an additional three-year post-warranty Operations, Support & Maintenance period.”
The tech company says it “shall also be offering tier-3 hosting services as well as training and a user Service Desk operating locally in Nigeria.”
Technology Times checks on the also shows that European Dynamics had in the preceding year announced that it has secured a World Bank funded Framework Agreement to implement e-Government Procurement to 35 Nigerian States.
“The Kaduna State of Nigeria,” the company’s announcement dated July 29, 2020 states, “acting as Lead Purchaser of the all Nigerian States, has awarded to EUROPEAN DYNAMICS (ED) a World Bank sponsored framework agreement for the gradual implementation of ED’ e-PPS Electronic Procurement platform throughout 35 States of Nigeria. Each State shall enter into a separate contract with ED and will implement a dedicated instance of e-PPS for all its public procurement procedures.”
The Nigerian States, “through the deliberations at the Nigeria Governor Forum (NGF), have decided to embark on the deployment of a centralized Software-as-a-Service (SaaS) e-Procurement solution across the states and for this reason they have selected ED and its line of Electronic Public Procurement products and services.”
According to ED, “The Framework Agreement is an important element of the World Bank’s States Transparency, Accountability and Sustainability (SFTAS) Program for Results (PforR) initiative and in particular towards “improved procurement practices for increased transparency and value for money.”
Centrality of User Acceptance Testing
At the centre of the arbitration dispute over the National e-Government Procurement (e-GP) System was the User Acceptance Test (UAT) conducted by Nigeria’s BPP. The UAT reportedly identified significant functional deficiencies, including critical omissions and errors affecting system performance.
The Nigerian Bureau argued that unlike conventional supply contracts where delivery may occur upon physical handover, software customisation projects are performance-validated. Delivery, it maintained, crystallises only upon satisfactory UAT confirming that the system operates in accordance with the technical requirements, statutory workflows and operational environment for which it was commissioned.
The tribunal accepted Nigeria’s position that the identified deficiencies fell within the vendor’s responsibility to remedy at no additional cost. It further held that the contractor, as the technical expert, bore the obligation to ensure that the delivered system complied with contractual requirements irrespective of earlier technical documents that might have been approved by the BPP.
The tribunal also found no evidence that the Bureau consented to the merger of multi-phase modules into a single phase.
“Nothing in the Contract suggests that such a merger is permissible, particularly given that payment is structured in phases. Consequently, the contractual framework was distorted,” it ruled.
Consequently, the arbitrator dismissed all claims by European Dynamics UK Ltd in their entirety.
BPP: Nigeria can no longer be taken for granted
Dr Adedokun, during a formal presentation of the award to the Attorney General of the Federation and Minister of Justice, Prince Lateef Fagbemi (SAN), described the outcome as an important signal for public sector technology contracting.
“This particular vendor has taken various African countries to court and won every single case. Nigeria is the first to defeat them. We stood our ground against one of the best legal teams in the world because we believed in the expertise of our own Nigerian legal professionals,” he said.
The DG expressed appreciation to the AGF for approving the proceedings, noting that without such support, Nigeria would have lost billions of naira that can now be spent on critical national development.
No longer business as usual, AGF says
Responding, the Attorney General of the Federation and Minister of Justice commended Adedokun’s decision and the performance of the legal team.
“Nigeria is a country blessed with both natural and human resources. This win sends a clear message to the international community: Nigeria has resonated. It is no longer business as usual. By standing up to European Dynamics, we have instilled courage in other African nations to protect their own resources,” he said.
The minister also commended President Bola Ahmed Tinubu for sustained support to institutional strengthening within the justice sector, saying: “We have a leader, mentor and father that can always watch our back. If he says leave it, we have no choice… he wants to nurture strong institutions.”
Implications for public sector technology contracts
The ruling underscores the importance of rigorous User Acceptance Testing, the government says, clearly defined milestones and expert-driven delivery standards in government software projects.
The legal representative for the BPP encouraged incorporation of lessons from the arbitration into ongoing e-procurement reforms to strengthen contract performance oversight and reduce the risk of future disputes.
With the tribunal’s decision now final, the outcome removes immediate financial liability for the Federal Government and provides judicial clarity on performance validation standards in complex public sector technology contracts tied to phased implementation and milestone-based payments.
Home
