OPINION

  • All
  • Opinion
true-cyber-resilience-is-business-enabler

True cyber resilience is a business enabler

byTechnology Times Contributor
05/06/2023
0

eft-africa-bright-electronic-funds-transfer

EFT: In Africa, bright future for electronic funds transfers

byTechnology Times Contributor
30/05/2023
0

what-hr-professionals-should-know-job-scams

What HR professionals need to know about job candidate scams

byTechnology Times Contributor
29/05/2023
0

proptech-innovating-property-transfer-for-future

Proptech: Innovating property transfer process for more efficient future

byTechnology Times Contributor
29/05/2023
0

staying-safe-onwhatsapp

Staying safe on WhatsApp as scammers eye popular messaging app

byTechnology Times Contributor
16/05/2023
0

nigeria-technology-for-gdp-or-employment

In Nigeria today, which is more important: GDP growth or employment growth?

byTechnology Times Contributor
19/04/2023
0

tech-solutions-must-match-business-context

Tech solutions are meaningless without business context

byTechnology Times Contributor
13/04/2023
0

emmanuel-asika-hp-nigeria-on-workplace-transformation

Workplace Transformation: How to incorporate human-centered solutions 

byTechnology Times Contributor
12/04/2023
0

e4 understands the current business challenges better than most, the company’s CIO, Fikile Sibiya says

Managing IT in dark times: CIO’s lessons from South Africa

byTechnology Times Contributor
31/03/2023
0

Mr Emmanuel Asika, HP Nigeria Country Head says employees are critical part of organisations' plans to address cybersecurity.

Cybersecurity:- Why employee collaboration is key 

byTechnology Times Contributor
30/03/2023
0

will-ai-replace-software-developers

Will AI replace software developers?

byTechnology Times Contributor
16/03/2023
0

financial-success-how-traders-can-step-up-games

How small businesses, traders can up their game for financial success

byTechnology Times Contributor
24/02/2023
0

Load More
  • Privacy Policy
  • Guest Post Guidelines
  • Advertising
  • Contact Us
  • Newsletter
Tuesday, June 6, 2023
No Result
View All Result
  • Login
Technology Times
Technology Times
No Result
View All Result

Unmasking The Digitally Excluded

Yunusa YaubyYunusa Yau
06/06/2022
in Conversations With Y.Z. Yau, Opinion
Reading Time: 6 mins read
1 0
A A
0
Share on FacebookShare on TwitterShare on LinkedinShare on WhatsAppShare on Telegram

Speculation is not a baseless pastime nor is it in the character of the lazy. It is a perfectly rational discourse, grounded in factual assumptions. I intend to indulge in one form of speculative discourse here and as I said, speculation is rooted in point of facts. Let me start with the factual to lay the basis of my speculation. It is a fact that we have moved from the era when government officials blithely told us that telephones were not for the poor to one in which government officials now routinely bemoan the digital exclusion of the poor. Today even the most rapacious business executive is wont to complain about the digitally excluded. Of course, they do this not from any moral ground, essentially because they see those left behind as an economic loss to their businesses and the country. Digitally unconnected people are a loss of telecommunication traffic which in itself is a major indicator of economic activities; not to talk of the money that users have to spend to generate this traffic or the business transactions that are facilitated by such traffic. Education, healthcare, commerce, communication and all sort of businesses benefit from connectivity. 

And thus, it is, we have moved from a defensive position of government that it cannot cater for the telecommunication needs of the poor to one in which government is worried that the poor are being digitally left behind. It wants to provide access to the poor.

Suddenly, we have all joined in the discourse about connecting the unconnected. Government officials routinely speak about what the government is doing to connect the unconnected and to bridge the internal digital divide. Somehow, in this, they assume or pretend to assume, unproblematically, that the internal dimension of the digital divide is sufficient to address its external dimensions but this is not possible and this is one problem of the discourse. 

Bridging the internal divide is about national leveling, that is getting everyone to access connectivity. It is improving teledensity and other similar indicators. But it tells us nothing of the fundamental differences in the insertion and use of digital technologies by different countries. By raising connectivity, we assure that more Nigerians are able to consume bandwidth, which we do not produce but procure from other countries. We consume more handsets and other digital devices that are manufactured in other countries and sold to us. We consume content that is uploaded by others, relegating us to downloading. We set up more websites only to host them in other countries where infrastructure is better and more reliable, contributing to the capital outflow from our country. We give out freely our data to data miners and entrepreneurs who make profits out of it while our citizens continue to live in their poverty that is exposed by the lack of digital privacy. 

Related Articles

true-cyber-resilience-is-business-enabler

True cyber resilience is a business enabler

05/06/2023
eft-africa-bright-electronic-funds-transfer

EFT: In Africa, bright future for electronic funds transfers

30/05/2023
what-hr-professionals-should-know-job-scams

What HR professionals need to know about job candidate scams

29/05/2023
proptech-innovating-property-transfer-for-future

Proptech: Innovating property transfer process for more efficient future

29/05/2023
staying-safe-onwhatsapp

Staying safe on WhatsApp as scammers eye popular messaging app

16/05/2023
nigeria-technology-for-gdp-or-employment

In Nigeria today, which is more important: GDP growth or employment growth?

19/04/2023

Three things remain starkly disturbing, which are all related to the international dimensions of the digital divide. One is that the digital divide is not just about teledensity and indicators but about the production and consumption of digital goods and services. In this, Nigeria remains a mere consuming country with no contribution to the global stock of production. Second, we remain largely consumers of content, with little contribution to the global cyber content. Third, and more significantly, we are further pushed to the edge of knowledge production in a world that is knowledge-based and knowledge-driven. And once you are left out of the effort at pushing the frontiers of knowledge, you will remain at the bottom of the development ladder. That is our situation today.

But there is another aspect to our peculiar discourse on the unconnected which leads me to my speculation. We talk about the unconnected in an abstract and dehumanized way that we do not know who they are or see the unconnected beyond mere figures. We do not even know how many of us are unconnected beyond the normalized euphemism of impersonal percentage that hides lot of things. In doing my speculation and in keeping with my premise that all speculations are grounded in facts, I start by using a government figure. In the National Broadband Plan document that is signed on behalf of the government by the Hon Minister of Communication and Digital Economy and with a foreword by no other person than the President himself, it says that there are 114 communities that are classified as either “underserved” or “underserved”. Stripped of the technicalities, this means these are the communities where GSM signal is either too week or is lacking altogether. These are officially the “unconnected.” Never mind that it is not clear what the definition of community is here as it can be misleading, given that we have many thousands of communities, 114 is not a significant proportion. However, it is said that the combined population of the people in these 114 communities is around 50 million people. This means that about 50 million Nigerians out of 200 million are unconnected. It means that one out of every four Nigerians is unconnected. This is more informative than just stating that there are 114 underserved and unserved communities. 

But access is not the only factor that limits against the use of digital systems. One significant factor is affordability. Of course affordability is relative as what was unaffordable yesterday could become affordable today or what is unaffordable for one group of persons could be affordable for another. Yet we know that affordability is a function of economic status. The poor are hardly able to own and maintain access. With a population of about 100 million living below the poverty line, it is reasonable to expect that at least a quarter of these people are living under extreme poverty and cannot afford access, meaning that at least 25 million more people cannot afford access. Added to the people lacking access, this gives us a figure of 70 million being digitally excluded. 

We now turn to people living with disabilities. Nigerian ICT sector is not known for its being disability-friendly. People cannot afford the special interface devices such as for those with either hearing or vision impairment, but even for physically-challenged people, we have known ICT facilities are located in buildings where there are no ramps. Now the Joint Association of People Living with Disabilities (JONAPID) has estimated that there are about 20 million people living with disabilities in Nigeria. Let us assume that about half of them cannot use ICTs either because they do not have the skills, or cannot afford it or do not have the appropriate interface devices. When we add these 10 million people to our tally, that takes us to 80 million being left behind. 

The next significant factor for effective use is awareness. People need to be aware about what ICTs could do to their lives before they can use them. We may assume that awareness has percolated the society but this is not true. I have seen academics who are not aware of what ICT meant for them and they do not know how to use them. I have seen many professionals, including journalists, judges, etc who think ICTs are not for them. Let us say about 10% of Nigerians do now know what ICT could do for them and do not want to use it. We now add this number to our tally above and get at least 100 million Nigerians that are digitally excluded. 

The last major militating factor relates to women and girls. This is both about culture as well as about the specific insertion of technology in society. With respect to culture, patriarchy has been resistant to allowing the autonomy of the female when it comes to communication because communication is a tool for control and for exercising powerful. Thus many women are literarily prevented from using digital spaces by their spouses. There are also those who prevent their wives from using digital spaces out of concern to “protect” the women from exposure to harmful and culturally corrupting content. Many parents who prevent their daughters from using digital technology fall into this category. Finally, women themselves have internalized the fear of harmful content online such as gender violence online, sexual harassment and loss of privacy to keep off from the internet. Women constitute about slightly more than half of the population of Nigeria, that means there are over 100 million of them. Let us say that it is just about 20 percent of this number that do not use the internet either because of fear or patriarchy or parental control, that gives us additional 20 million to add on our tally which takes us to about N120 million Nigerians who are left behind digitally.

So when government talks about the unconnected, it is actually hiding this huge number away from us, that is more than half Nigerians are digitally excluded. What actual strategies does the government have in order to include these people who are currently digitally included? As of now, we do not even have a national digital inclusion agenda. We do not have an ICT and Disability policy; we have no real affordability bridging mechanism in spite of the University Service Provision Fund (USPF). We have no national strategy for transforming the economy from an ICT consumer to one that can be both producer and consumer? Are there plans to address our poor knowledge generation infrastructure in the country such that can deal with the issues that ASUU is raising in our universities for instance?
My questions, like the figures, are speculative, only a government answer can dismiss speculations and bring out a certain sure-footed narrative that will address the issues raised here. 

Share18Tweet11Share3SendShare
ADVERTISEMENT
Yunusa Yau

Yunusa Yau

Related Articles

Market Updates

Aqil takes charge of BankTech in MTN Fintech unit, Momo

06/06/2023
aqil-heads-banktech-mtn-fintech-unit-momo

MTN Group has appointed a former banker, M. Mudassar Aqil,...

Read more
byTechnology Times Staff
0 Comments
Opinion

True cyber resilience is a business enabler

05/06/2023
true-cyber-resilience-is-business-enabler

Cyber resilience, which is much more than just cybersecurity, may...

Read more
byTechnology Times Contributor
0 Comments
Technology Insights

What digital superstitions do internet users believe? 

05/06/2023
digital-superstitions-internet-users-believe

Kaspersky recently analysed what digital superstitions internet users believe in...

Read more
byTechnology Times Staff
0 Comments
Technology Insights

ChatGPT: Will AI chatbots help fight cyberscam?

05/06/2023
chatgpt-will-ai-chatbots-fight-cyberscam

Kaspersky experts have conducted research studying ChatGPT phishing links detection...

Read more
byTechnology Times Staff
0 Comments
Tech News

Nigerians alerted as new job scam targets LinkedIn users

31/05/2023
nigerians-alerted-of-linkedin-job-scams

LinkedIn users have been warned of phishing scams targeting individuals...

Read more
byTechnology Times Staff
0 Comments
Tech Market Updates

Data centre expert named Vertiv Africa Director

30/05/2023
jonathan-duncan-named-vertiv-director

Vertiv has appointed Jonathan Duncan as application engineering and technical...

Read more
byTechnology Times Staff
0 Comments

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

I agree to the Terms & Conditions and Privacy Policy.

16 − nine =

ADVERTISEMENT
CrownCrystal Technologies CrownCrystal Technologies CrownCrystal Technologies
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT

LATEST ARTICLES

aqil-heads-banktech-mtn-fintech-unit-momo

Aqil takes charge of BankTech in MTN Fintech unit, Momo

06/06/2023
true-cyber-resilience-is-business-enabler

True cyber resilience is a business enabler

05/06/2023
digital-superstitions-internet-users-believe

What digital superstitions do internet users believe? 

05/06/2023
chatgpt-will-ai-chatbots-fight-cyberscam

ChatGPT: Will AI chatbots help fight cyberscam?

05/06/2023
nigerians-alerted-of-linkedin-job-scams

Nigerians alerted as new job scam targets LinkedIn users

31/05/2023
ADVERTISEMENT
ADVERTISEMENT

Popular News

  • Airtel Nigeria pays N58.7b to renew spectrum

    Airtel Nigeria pays N58.7b to renew spectrum

    101 shares
    Share 40 Tweet 25
  • PC: How to spot symptoms of CPU failure

    212 shares
    Share 85 Tweet 53
  • EFT: In Africa, bright future for electronic funds transfers

    86 shares
    Share 34 Tweet 22
  • Nigerians alerted as new job scam targets LinkedIn users

    86 shares
    Share 34 Tweet 22
  • Tech solutions are meaningless without business context

    86 shares
    Share 34 Tweet 22

Recommended

  • Tech News
nigerians-alerted-of-linkedin-job-scams

Nigerians alerted as new job scam targets LinkedIn users

31/05/2023
cybersecurity-reducing-cyber-risk-next-gen-technology

Cybersecurity: Reducing cyber risk with next-gen technology

30/05/2023
nigeria-unveils-national-blockchain-policy-team

Nigeria unveils National Blockchain Policy team tomorrow

15/05/2023
Airtel Nigeria pays N58.7b to renew spectrum

Airtel Nigeria pays N58.7b to renew spectrum

09/05/2023
konga-warns-of-scam-website

Konga warns customers of scam website

04/05/2023
bon-ncc-600-mhz-spectrum-sale-threat

BON: NCC’s 600 MHz spectrum sale plan threatens 80% of Nigeria’s TV viewers 

29/04/2023
Load More
ADVERTISEMENT
Facebook Twitter Youtube LinkedIn RSS

ABOUT TECHNOLOGY TIMES

Technology Times

Nigeria Technology Media Group

Founded in 2004, Technology Times’ trusted technology news, market intelligence, views and business services reach readers and partners across Nigeria, Africa and beyond.

Advertising

Contct Us

LEGAL & COMPLIANCE

Home

TT Privacy Policy

TT Terms & Conditions

TT Website Disclaimer

TT Guest Post Guidelines

Contact TT

LATEST ARTICLES

aqil-heads-banktech-mtn-fintech-unit-momo

Aqil takes charge of BankTech in MTN Fintech unit, Momo

06/06/2023
true-cyber-resilience-is-business-enabler

True cyber resilience is a business enabler

05/06/2023
digital-superstitions-internet-users-believe

What digital superstitions do internet users believe? 

05/06/2023
chatgpt-will-ai-chatbots-fight-cyberscam

ChatGPT: Will AI chatbots help fight cyberscam?

05/06/2023
nigerians-alerted-of-linkedin-job-scams

Nigerians alerted as new job scam targets LinkedIn users

31/05/2023
jonathan-duncan-named-vertiv-director

Data centre expert named Vertiv Africa Director

30/05/2023
eft-africa-bright-electronic-funds-transfer

EFT: In Africa, bright future for electronic funds transfers

30/05/2023

TOP READ ARTICLES

  • Airtel Nigeria pays N58.7b to renew spectrum

    Airtel Nigeria pays N58.7b to renew spectrum

    101 shares
    Share 40 Tweet 25
  • PC: How to spot symptoms of CPU failure

    212 shares
    Share 85 Tweet 53
  • EFT: In Africa, bright future for electronic funds transfers

    86 shares
    Share 34 Tweet 22
  • Nigerians alerted as new job scam targets LinkedIn users

    86 shares
    Share 34 Tweet 22
  • Tech solutions are meaningless without business context

    86 shares
    Share 34 Tweet 22

©2023 Technology Times, owned and operated by Digital Transformation Media Limited, Nigeria.

No Result
View All Result
  • Home
  • Technology Times Big Story
  • Tech News
  • Interviews
  • Tech Market Updates
  • Consumer Tech
  • Interviews
  • Opinion
  • Digital Transformation Series

©2023 Technology Times, owned and operated by Digital Transformation Media Limited, Nigeria.

Welcome Back!

OR

Login to your account below

Forgotten Password?

Retrieve your password

Please enter your username or email address to reset your password.

Log In

Add New Playlist

This website uses cookies. By continuing to use this website you are giving consent to cookies being used. Visit our Privacy Policy Page.